✎ en:tabisuke [policy-debate.org]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.

====== tabisuke ======

Presentation draft 

https://wikimania2017.wikimedia.org/wiki/Submissions/Wikiparliament_-_enhancing_both_freedom_and_efficiency_on_wiki%3F

 About the speaker
   A.k.a. Tabisuke
   Independent researcher
   Tokyo, Japan

Table of contents

  1. The essence of parliamentary principles
  
  Freedom  ---- Efficiency
  (x) central control
  (o) autonomous distributed control

   2. Examples of parliamentary rules – traditional / for wiki
  
  Motion
  Second
  Debate
  Vote

  3. Vote
  
  A variety of votes – decision making
    Silence (no objection)
    Voice vote
    Majority vote
    Special majority vote
    Unanimous consent
  
    Low cost --- High cost
    Low importance -- important
  
  Who should be a voter ?
    Committer
    Everyone
    Those who are interested, e.g., those who edited the doc three times

  4. Second
  
  What is the object of seconding ?

  5. Motion
  
  Which motion first ?

  6. Debate
  
  How to (effectively) debate ?
    Motion centered
    Pro/con switching
    Restrict frequent speech by one participant
    Visualize positions – pro/con/neither

  7. Structuring policy debate and decision making
  
  Separate out facts and values (weighting/prioritizing)
  Pursuit consensus on facts 
  Explicit confrontation and pursuit consensus on values
  Vote + Calculation

  8. A wikiparliament “maturity model”
  
  Level 1: Introduce seconding for editing
  Level 2: Support drafting and publishing cycle with motion
  Level 3: Support voting
  Level 4: Support debating
  Level 5: Implement structural decision making  

  9. Debate !
  
  Pro/con ?
  Suitable/unsuitable use case ?
  Modification ?

en/tabisuke.1497381355.txt.gz · Last modified: 2017/06/14 04:15 (external edit)

policy-debate.org

Site Tools

User Tools

Site Tools

Page Tools

User Tools